Sissy's Pizza Menu

Sissy's Pizza, located at 2537 Otisco Valley Rd in Marietta, NY, offers a warm, authentic pizza experience that has captured the hearts of locals. Known for its flavorful, generously topped pizzas, Sissy’s delights with a perfect crust that strikes the balance between chewy and crisp, avoiding the dreaded paper-thin texture. Their pepperoni pizzas stand out, loaded with rich cheese and savory slices, making each bite satisfying and memorable.

Beyond pizza, Sissy’s impresses with standout dishes like the grilled chicken sandwich, praised for its robust flavor profile and freshness. The wings, while delicious, may benefit from a touch more cooking to reach perfection. The friendly, approachable staff and cozy setting—including a quaint indoor dining area and an inviting picnic table outside—enhance the overall experience. Whether you dine in or take out, Sissy’s Pizza combines quality ingredients with genuine hospitality, making it a must-try destination for pizza lovers.